← Research

Aligning with Logic: Measuring, Evaluating and Improving Logical Preference Consistency in Large Language Models

Yinhong Liu, Zhijiang Guo, Tianya Liang, Ehsan Shareghi, Ivan Vulić, Nigel Collier

Large Language Models (LLMs) are expected to be predictable and trustworthy to support reliable decision-making systems. Yet current LLMs often show inconsistencies in their judgments. In this work, we examine logical preference consistency as a foundational requirement for building more dependable LLM systems, ensuring stable and coherent decision-making while minimizing erratic or contradictory outputs. To quantify the logical preference consistency, we propose a universal evaluation framework based on three fundamental properties: transitivity, commutativity and negation invariance. Through extensive experimentation across diverse LLMs, we demonstrate that these properties serve as strong indicators of judgment robustness. Furthermore, we introduce a data refinement and augmentation technique, REPAIR, that enhances logical consistency while maintaining alignment with human preferences. Finally, we show that improving consistency leads to better performance in LLM-driven logic-based algorithms, reinforcing stability and coherence in decision-making systems.

PDF ↗

Models

Loading
EVIDENCE / COMPARISON

Benchmarks

Explore every benchmark

Loading

These charts contain model-linked results. The charts above also include unlinked source profiles. Compare scores within each evaluation. Model quality, usage, transparency and system performance measure different things.

Install TensorTrace